Who's rating what horror?
This data from Metacritic regards the film Sinister.It received a better score then Scream so it is clear that the market is wanting paranormal films more then slashers. However the difference in score is of a minority so we will keep a slight flicker of slasher and more of paranormal within our OTS.
As we stated before Sinister gets a higher rating then Scream 4. However there are more reviews for Scream so we would take this into consideration and ensure that the slasher loving individuals enjoy our OTS.